COMMENSAL ISSUE 95


The Newsletter of the Philosophical Discussion Group
Of British Mensa

Previous Article in Current Issue

Number 95 : February 1999

Next Article in Current Issue


ARTICLES
7th February 1999 : Theo Todman

EDITORIAL

Firstly, you’ll notice we’ve shifted to a new font (Times New Roman). New member Alan Edmonds reckons it is easier to read. This is the "official" font we use at work, so I have an in-built, albeit irrational, aversion to it. However, I agree with Alan that it may well be easier to read, so we’re giving it a go.

Secondly, and this should probably have been the first point, the Newsletter is a month late - an advance on last time’s, which was two month’s late, but hardly a return to normal service ! Today, I received a letter from Anthony Owens asking how SIG members can know whether their failure to receive a newsletter as advertised is due to the dysfunction of the SIGSec or Mensa House (Anthony put the question more kindly and subtly, of course). As it happens, he’s suffered from a two-pronged attack - my fault for Commensal & (presumably) Mensa House’s for PhiSIGma. Anthony suggested a page in Mensa Magazine listing the SIGs & their latest newsletters. I’ll suggest this to the SIGs Officer, Mark Griffin, who’ll read this anyway as he’s a member of PDG. I’ve occasionally thought that I ought to send a letter out on schedule (ie. in the first week of the month) saying that Commensal is going to be late (if it is), but presumed that some of you (mainly the "paying members") would object to the frittering away of funds. Maybe I should just try to get the thing out on time.


New Members

As usual, we welcome our new members to the SIG. Nine new members this time, so welcome to :-

  • Tony Hill
  • Dr. Alan Edmonds
  • Jim Crockett
  • Cy Hinton
  • Sheila Chadwick
  • Karin Reinmueller
  • Steve Brown
  • Kyle Cook
  • Barbara McGoun
  •  


    PDG Conference

    Thanks be unto Roger Farnworth for suggesting the format for the May ’99 Conference at Braziers. I’ve left it much as he submitted it in November last year, except that I’ve removed references to the guest speaker, whose favour I have curried insufficiently, I expect, to engage him this year. Everything is provisional, so let me know your thoughts. Also, see the notes following the draft schedule of events.

    Friday

    07/05/99

    18:00 - 19:30

    Arrive

    19:45

    Supper

    21:00

    Introduction "in the round"

    21:30

    Debate on Determinism or Freewill (Roger Farnworth & ...)

    Saturday

    08/05/99

    08:30

    Breakfast

    09:45

    Plan afternoon discussion - choose two subjects

    10:00

    Talk and Discussion: Consciousness (Theo Todman)

    11:00

    Coffee

    11:30 - 12:45

    Talk and Discussion (eg. on Philosophy of Science or Ethics)

    13:00

    Lunch

    Afternoon

    Free

    16:15

    Tea

    17:00 - 18:45

    Two subjects raised at the morning’s planning meeting

    20:00

    Informal Discussion (Pub, Lounge, ...)

    Sunday

    09/05/99

    08:30

    Breakfast

    10:00

    Talk & Discussion: Is it Rational to be Religious ? (Theo Todman)

    11:00

    Coffee

    11:30 - 12:45

    Talk & Discussion: ... any volunteers ??

    13:00

    Lunch

    14:00

    Planning next year’s Conference

    14:30

    Departure

    Notes

     

    1.

    The programme makes provision for plenty of spare time for informal discussion in the pub, at meals or in the lounge.

    2.

    Roger Farnworth will arrive at 19:00 on the Friday and meet all guests as they arrive & show them to their rooms.

    3.

    At the Friday’s introductory session we will encourage flexibility throughout, and seek to have each session chaired by a different volunteer.

    4.

    We need a volunteer for the Free Will side of the opening debate. Any takers ? Failing that, any alternative topics - with a volunteer to debate.

    5.

    A person by the name of Theo Todman is down to talk on two subjects. The first will be an update on Consciousness, straight from the King’s College London conference noted below, at which several of the internationally renowned experts will hopefully have appeared.

    6.

    My second talk, on the philosophical issues associated with adopting a religious outlook on life, is a topic of great interest to me but may not be to others. Anyone not liking this topic is welcome to suggest another, provided they deliver the talk on their chosen subject, that is !

    7.

    Volunteers are required for the other remaining Saturday and Sunday slots. Braziers is a small, informal conference, so no-one need fear being insufficiently professional or profound. A high level of participation by attendees is, however, essential for the conference to be a success.

    8.

    In default of volunteers for formal talks, we’ll discuss the various hot potatoes that have arisen in Commensal over the last couple of years.



    PDG Conference Administrative Details

    I repeat here some details from previous issues of Commensal. The conference is to be held at Braziers College, Ipsden, Wallingford, Oxon., OX10 6AN, over Friday - Sunday, 7th-9th May 1999. Braziers College was founded in 1950 as the Braziers School of Integrated Social Research to study practical ways of living in a group. It now operates partly as a community, and partly as an adult education college. It has a country-house atmosphere, and is situated in its own attractive grounds in the Chiltern countryside. The full fee, including accommodation and catering, is £92, and early booking is advisable. Apply for further details to the College at the above address (Tel: 01491 680221). A deposit of £20 is payable. Please book directly with the College - I will keep in touch with them periodically to see how things are going. Partners, whether Mensans or not, are welcome.


    King’s College London - Philosophy Lectures & Conferences

    Here follows some information gleaned from the King’s College London web-site (http://kcl.ac.uk). I’ll be attending the first conference on Consciousness, all being well, and will report on it at the Mensa Conference at Braziers, as noted above. Please note that none of the conferences or lectures below are anything to do with Mensa ! Nor, sadly, will I be able to attend many of the events. I merely draw your attention to them as another example of the philosophical surfeit those of us within striking distance of London have to dine on. Note that for the KCL Conferences one must sit on hard chairs and be lectured at, while for the PDG conference you sit in armchairs, as befits philosophers, and participate !


    Centre for Philosophical Studies

    Consciousness

    International Conference 24-25 April 1999

    Speakers and Titles:

    • Professor Ned Block (New York University): Consciousness and Representation
    • Professor David Chalmers (University of Arizona): How Can We Construct A Science of Consciousness ?
    • Professor Daniel Dennett (Tufts University): The Hard Question: And Then What Happens ?
    • Professor Susan Greenfield (University of Oxford): The Chemistry of Consciousness
    • Professor Nicholas Humphrey (London School of Economics): How to Solve the Mind-Body Problem
    • Professor John O'Keefe (University College London): Consciousness as a Brain Process
    • Professor David Papineau (King's College London): Are Theories of Consciousness Misconceived ?
    • Professor John Searle (University of California, Berkeley): The Structure of Consciousness

    Registration Fee : The registration fee is £75 until 28 February 1999, after which a late registration fee of an additional £20 will be charged. (Cheques should be made payable to "King's College London".)

    Refreshments : The registration fee will include the cost of coffee and tea on both days.
    There will be a Conference Reception to which all registered members of the conference are invited.
    In addition to the registration fee there will be charges for lunch on 24 April (£14), dinner on 24 April (£18) and lunch on 25 April (£14) for those who wish to eat on campus. For those who do not wish to eat on campus there are many cafés, pubs and restaurants in the immediate vicinity.

    Accommodation : There are fifty single rooms available at a cost of £25 per night for bed and breakfast at Rosebery Hall of Residence, London School of Economics. These will be allocated on a first come, first served basis.

    All enquiries to and application forms from : Dr Tony Dale, Centre for Philosophical Studies, King's College London, Strand, London WC2R 2LS; Tel 0171-873 2585 email a.dale@kcl.ac.uk


    King’s College London

    Humanities Research Centres
    Centre for Philosophical Studies

    Events Diary

    Public Lectures :-

    • Note : Several interesting lectures are now sadly in the past, namely : Professor Anthony Flew: Could We Survive Our Own Deaths ? Dr Michael Stšltzner (Vienna Circle Institute, Vienna): What Lakatos can teach the Mathematical Physicist. Lord Quinton: The Episode of Ordinary Language Philosophy. Professor Anthony O'Hear (University of Bradford): Popper: Science and Politics. However the following are still to come :-
    • Wednesday 24 February 1999, 5.15pm, Room 35B, Main Building : Professor Robert Thomas (University of Manitoba): Reuben Hersh's Philosophical Project and Beyond
    • Wednesday 3 March 1999, 5.15pm, Committee Room : Dr James Gasser (Universities of Lausanne and Neuchâtel): Logic and Metaphor
    • Wednesday 10 March 1999, 5.15pm, Council Room : Dr Zuzana Parusnikova (Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic): Health and Power: The Disciplinary Gaze in Modern Medicine
    • Wednesday 24 March 1999, 5.15pm, Council Room : Professor Christopher Hookway (University of Sheffield): Naturalism and Interpretation: Quine and Davidson
    • Wednesday 12 May 1999, 5.15pm, Council Room : Professor John Haldane (University of St Andrews): Philosophy and the Silencing of Religion
    • Wednesday 19 May 1999, 5.15pm, Room 228, Strand Building : Anthony Hill: Art and Mathematics

    Lectures held in conjunction with the Philosophy Programme of the School of Advanced Study, University of London
    History of the Problems of Philosophy: The Problem of Perception

    Every Tuesday at 6.00pm, from 20 April 1999 to 29 June 1999

    Room 349, Senate House, Malet Street, WC1
    Speakers include:

    Professor Julia Annas (University of Arizona), Professor Victor Caston (Brown University), Dr John Driver (Birkbeck College, London), Dr JC Field (Birkbeck College, London), Dr Marina Frasca-Spada (University of Cambridge), Professor Gary Hatfield (University of Pennsylvania), Dr MGF Martin (University College, London), Paul Snowdon (University of Oxford)

    Further details may be found at http://www.sas.ac.uk/Philosophy. For all enquiries about this series please telephone 0171 862 8683.


    An Event held in conjunction with the Centre for Hellenic Studies, King's College London and the Bimal Matilal Lectureship, King's College London
    Greek and Indian Philosophy: A Discussion Panel

    Friday 5 March 1999, 5.00pm, The Great Hall

    • Ambassador Vassilis Vitsaxis (formerly Greek Ambassador to India): Questions based on his book, Plato and the Upanishads
    • Professor Richard Gombrich (Boden Professor of Sanskrit, University of Oxford): On the Dialogue between the Greek King Milinda and a Buddhist Monk
    • Professor Richard Sorabji (King's College London): Plotinus and India
    • Dr Jonardon Ganeri (University of Nottingham) and Dr Chakravarthi Ram-Prasad (University of Cambridge): Common Concerns in Greek and Indian Philosophy

    Enquiries to Centre for Hellenic Studies, King's College London, tel 0171 873 2088


    Conferences

    One-Day Conference on: Philosophy and Computing
    In conjunction with the Centre for Computing in the Humanities, King’s College London

    Friday 19 February 1999, 9.45am - 6.05pm, Committee Room

    Programme:

    9.45: Registration

    10.00: Dr Peter Millican (University of Leeds): Using Computers in Philosophy

    11.15-11.35: coffee

    11.35:Dr Sylvia Berryman (King's College London): Results from Data-Base Research in Ancient Greek Philosophy

    12.50-14.00: lunch break

    14.00: Dr Luciano Floridi (University of Oxford): Should There Be a Philosophy of Computing?
    15.15:Professor Donald Gillies (King's College London): How Philosophy has Helped Computing
    16.30-16.50: coffee

    16.50:Professor Peter Gibbins (University of Exeter): The Digitization of Philosophy

    There is no registration fee but please let Dr A Dale know beforehand if you are attending.


    Next Issue of Commensal

    15th March 1999 is the closing date for contributions to April’s Commensal (C96). Apologies for the limited and selective commentary by me in C95 - it’s this or nothing at the moment, I’m afraid.

    Best wishes,

    Theo



    Previous Article in Current Issue (Commensal 95)
    Next Article in Current Issue (Commensal 95)
    Index to Current Issue (Commensal 95)